Bioinspired Controlling the Surface Wettability of Materials by Femtosecond Laser: Current Progress and Challenges (Invited)
Jiale Yong, and Dong Wu
SignificanceWettability is as a crucial physical and chemical property of solid surfaces. Surfaces with unique wettability, especially, attract considerable attention. Their significant impact spans various domains, including energy use, environmental protection, chemical engineering, healthcare, sustainable development, military defense, manufacturing, and agricultural breeding. Consequently, special wettability, particularly extreme wettability (i.e., superwettability), is emerging as a hot research topic in the field of micro- and nano-manufacturing. The study of superwettability originates from observing nature’s unique wetting phenomena and deeply investigating their formation mechanisms. Numerous plants and animals have evolved surfaces with special wetting properties to adapt to their environments. Inspired by natural superwettability, a range of micro/nano-manufacturing technologies have been employed to create various superwetting materials. These technologies include machining, photolithography, chemical etching, template replication, plasma etching, vapor deposition, electrochemical methods, the sol-gel process, electrospinning, electrochemical deposition, self-assembly, and spray/dip coating. Although existing microfabrication methods can produce superwetting structures with outstanding properties, traditional approaches face several technical challenges in achieving superwettability. These include complex preparation steps, constraints to specific substrate materials, and a lack of flexibility. Notably, most micromachining methods are limited to processing certain materials (for example, lithography is restricted to photosensitive polymers) or struggle with the precise design of micro/nanostructures (such as chemical etching, which can rapidly create large areas of uniform microstructures but faces difficulties in patterning these structures). These limitations significantly hinder the practical application of surfaces with engineered superwettability. Developing a versatile microfabrication technology capable of preparing various superwetting surfaces remains a significant challenge.ProgressThe characteristics of ultrashort pulse width and ultrahigh peak power establish femtosecond lasers as pivotal tools in modern extreme and ultra-precision manufacturing. Given that surface microstructure significantly influences the wettability of solid materials, femtosecond laser processing can create a variety of superwettability by constructing specialized microscale and nanoscale structures on material surfaces. Superhydrophilicity can be realized by forming sufficiently rough microstructures on inherently hydrophilic materials. In the case of superhydrophobicity, materials are generally categorized into two types. For intrinsically hydrophobic materials, superhydrophobicity can be directly achieved by preparing hierarchical micro/nanostructures on the substrate surfaces. For inherently hydrophilic materials, after forming surface microstructures with a femtosecond laser, it is often necessary to further reduce the surface energy via chemical modification. On a superhydrophilic surface, water droplets spread rapidly, while a superhydrophobic surface functions to repel water, offering waterproofing. Superoleophobic surfaces are categorized into two types, effective in air and underwater, respectively. To create superoleophobic surfaces in air, re-entrant bending microstructures are introduced, combined with stringent low-surface-energy chemical modifications. These microstructures are directly crafted onto the surface of hydrophilic substrates to realize underwater superoleophobicity. Superoleophobic surfaces repel oily liquids and some organic liquids with low surface energy. Generally, superhydrophilic surfaces exhibit superaerophobicity underwater, and superhydrophobic surfaces demonstrate superaerophilicity underwater. The superaerophobic surface effectively repels bubble adhesion, while the superaerophilic surface can adsorb tiny bubbles in water. Slippery surfaces created using femtosecond laser-induced porous network microstructures enable droplet contact with the material surface in a liquid/liquid mode, repelling various liquids. Underwater superpolymphobicity is achieved by constructing micro/nanostructures on the surface of hydrophilic materials. This property is useful for preventing the adhesion of liquid polymers to solid materials and assisting in the design of polymer shapes. Irrespective of superhydrophobicity or superhydrophilicity, femtosecond laser-induced microstructures exhibit supermetalphobicity. By designing patterned microstructures on the surface of flexible materials using a femtosecond laser, liquid metals can be transformed into circuits, enabling the creation of flexible electronic devices. Superwetting surfaces with controllable adhesion are achievable through the femtosecond laser-based design of surface micro/nanostructures. The adhesion level of these prepared surfaces to droplets can range from very low to very high. Anisotropic wettability is attainable on the anisotropically structured surfaces crafted by the femtosecond laser. Reversibly switchable wettability on these laser-structured surfaces can be achieved through three approaches: adjusting surface chemistry, modifying surface microtopography, and altering the ambient environment. The special wettability endows femtosecond laser-treated materials with a range of practical applications, such as waterproofing, self-cleaning, droplet manipulation, liquid patterning, buoyancy enhancement, tiny drop and bubble release, oil-water separation, water/gas separation, anti-icing, anti-corrosion, underwater drag reduction, water/fog collection, microfluidics, flexible circuits/electronics, cell engineering, biomedical engineering, seawater desalination, surface-enhanced Raman scattering, and more.Conclusions and ProspectsThis review comprehensively outlines the advancements in femtosecond laser processing for manipulating the surface wettability of materials. By employing femtosecond lasers to design micro/nanostructures on various material surfaces, a range of unique wettabilities has been achieved. These include superhydrophilicity, superhydrophobicity, superoleophobicity, underwater superaerophobicity and superaerophilicity, slippery liquid-infused porous surfaces, underwater superpolymphobicity, supermetalphobicity, controllable adhesion, anisotropic wettability, and smart switchable wettability. The practical applications of these femtosecond laser-structured superwetting materials have been diverse and significant.Currently, the technology of femtosecond laser-controlled surface wettability faces several challenges. A major bottleneck is processing efficiency, which still restricts the broader application of femtosecond laser micromachining technology. Despite new strategies such as laser parallel processing and light-field regulation, efficiency falls short of industrial application requirements. Additionally, if the laser focus deviates significantly from the material surface, then the desired microstructures cannot be effectively prepared. This defocusing issue also makes it difficult to create uniform superwetting micro/nanostructures on complex curved surfaces. Moreover, similar to surfaces prepared by other methods, femtosecond laser-induced superwettability surfaces encounter stability issues in practical applications. These surfaces often lose their initial extreme wettability when exposed to friction or specific operating environments. Thus, future research in this field should address these bottlenecks, enhancing the practicality and scalability of superwetting materials prepared by femtosecond lasers for real-world applications.
  • Jan. 10, 2024
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 51, Issue 1, 0102002 (2024)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL231364
Advances in the Study of Interfaces in Laser Additive Manufacturing of Multi‐Materials with Significant Differences in Physical Properties (Invited)
Xiaojing Sun, Ding Yuan, Chao Wei, Xiao Yang, and Lin Li
SignificanceWith the increasing demand for structural functionality and lightweight in aerospace and marine engineering fields, a growing requirement has emerged for diversity in material and structural properties. For some aerospace components, different structural parts are required to operate in different environments, and traditional homogeneous materials are inadequate. Especially in extreme service environments, materials and structures must integrate multiple properties to address specific engineering or scientific requirements. For example, the same part may exhibit significantly different thermal, mechanical, acoustic, and electrical properties in different locations. Such material combinations with significant physical differences, including metal-metal, metal-polymer, metal-ceramic, and polymer-ceramic, are referred to as materials with significant differences in their physical properties. Development of such materials is critical for weight reduction, and product performance and reliability improvement. With multi-material laser additive manufacturing science and technology development, it is possible to integrate the preparation of materials and components with significant differences in physical properties.However, the interface problem that occurs in multi-material laser additive manufactured materials in this specific context is particularly important. The interfacial bonding quality of materials with significant differences in physical properties remains a significant problem. Interface defects, excessive residual stress, and cracking severely limit the multi-material laser additive manufacturing of these types of materials. Therefore, this study reviews research advances in laser additive manufactured multi-materials with significant differences in physical properties, focusing on interface problems, optimization methods, modeling and simulation.ProgressCurrently, multi-material laser additive manufacturing technology primarily includes: laser powder bed fusion, laser-directed energy deposition, laser-induced forward transfer, multiphoton fabrication, and hybrid multi-material laser additive manufacturing. In the multi-material laser additive manufacturing process, interface problems arise from laser absorption rate differences, thermophysical properties and brittle phase formation at the interface between materials with significant physical property differences. These issues lead to the formation of defects, cracks and residual stress at the interface during fabrication and may even result in interface material delamination and debonding. Therefore, this study investigates interface problems based on the three aforementioned aspects.A literature analysis is conducted on interface optimization methods for laser additive manufacturing in this context in terms of process optimization, functional gradient design, and integrated manufacturing systems (Fig.10). These provide methods for achieving high-quality formation of materials with significant differences in physical properties. Process optimization primarily includes: parameter optimization, heat treatment, and laser re-melting. Functional gradient design primarily includes: transition and gradient bonding, and interface structure design. Integrated manufacturing systems primarily includes: laser wavelength selection and multi-energy field hybrids. This study provides a detailed explanation for process optimization and functional gradient design, which are widely used optimization methods. Research progress regarding modeling and simulation of laser additive manufacturing of multi-materials with significant differences in physical properties is expounded. Modeling and simulation are important methods for investigating the influence of material property differences on heterogeneous interface formation. By simulating the effects of laser powder bed additive manufacturing parameters on the thermal behavior of heterogeneous interfaces at both macroscopic and mesoscopic scales, optimization of formation parameters can be achieved.Conclusions and ProspectsThis study reviews research advances on interfaces in the laser additive manufacturing of multi-materials with significant differences in physical properties. This includes multi-material laser additive manufacturing technologies, interface problems and optimization methods, and modeling and simulation in this specific context. Interface optimization methods are also summarized to identify high-quality heterogeneous material formation and to promote the research and application of multi-material laser additive manufacturing.
  • Jan. 10, 2024
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 51, Issue 1, 0102003 (2024)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL231414
Development of Refractory High Entropy Alloys by Laser Additive Manufacturing: Regulating Material Properties and Manufacturing Processes (Invited)
Dichen Li, Hang Zhang, and Jianglong Cai
SignificanceRefractory high entropy alloy (RHEA) has superior properties such as high strength, high hardness, high temperature resistance and high corrosion resistance, which is expected to become a new material of high-temperature structure. RHEA has huge application prospects in aerospace, nuclear engineering, weapons and other fields. At present, the RHEA prepared by vacuum arc melting technology has some problems, such as large size limitation, difficult formation of complex structure, serious component segregation and long development cycle. RHEA formed by laser additive manufacturing has obvious advantages such as uniform composition, excellent microstructure and properties, integral forming of complex shape, etc. It has application potential in raw material development and high-performance parts preparation, so it has received hot attention in the research field.ProgressThe primary task of RHEA formed by laser additive manufacturing is defect control. The microstructure defects of RHEA produced by laser additive manufacturing can be divided into cracks and pores. The crack defects can be divided into hot crack and cold crack. The addition of a small number of nanoparticles, process optimization and post-treatment can eliminate the crack defects. Pore defects can be divided into four types: unfused pore, metallurgical pore, micro pore and shrinkage pore. The main control method of pore defects is process optimization. By controlling the defects, the forming of RHEA and its properties are improved greatly. Additive manufacturing of RHEAs is an effective method to develop new alloys quickly. The process parameters of laser additive technology are numerous, strongly coupled and nonlinear. Single-factor experiment, numerical overlap optimization of molten pool and numerical simulation are the rapid optimization strategies for laser additive manufacturing of RHEA. Laser additive manufacturing enables rapid development iterations of RHEA. By mechanical mixing powder or preforming alloy powder, laser additive manufacturing technology can realize the formation of various metal powders by varying component ratios, and realize the rapid screening and performance evaluation of alloy composition. NbMoTaW alloys have very high strength but poor ductility, which can be strengthened and toughened by appropriately adding low melting point ductility elements and reducing brittle elements in the matrix. HfNbTaZr alloy has good plasticity, but the yield strength is generally low, which can be strengthened by adding strengthening elements. Due to the difficulty of controlling the forming crack defects, there are few studies on the tensile properties of RHEA formed by laser additive manufacturing. And more research work is needed, especially major breakthroughs in material mechanism and forming process. Finally, the complex structural parts formed by laser additive manufacturing for RHEA is still in the initial attempt stage.Conclusions and ProspectsIn this paper, the research on RHEAs formed by laser additive manufacturing is reviewed, and the development approaches, forming process and defect control, and the main research and challenges on mechanical properties of refractory high entropy alloys at multiple temperature stages are summarized. The research progress of complex parts of refractory high entropy alloy is introduced. Finally, the future application and development trend of RHEA formed by additive manufacturing are discussed. The integrated manufacturing of materials and shape is essential for RHEA, and laser additive manufacturing is the development direction of component manufacturing. The progress of materials and processes is the prerequisite for the integral forming of complex components in RHEA formed by laser additive manufacturing. At present, it has the ability to form simple samples, so more in-depth research is needed to accelerate the industrial application process of integrated manufacturing of shape and properties for RHEA in laser additive manufacturing.
  • Jan. 10, 2024
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 51, Issue 1, 0102001 (2024)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL231215
Microstructure Formation and Evolution Mechanism of Laser Rapid Melted Nickel Based Alloy Based on Composition Gradient
Ronggui Lu, Xinyue Zhang, Xu Cheng, Jia Li, Dong Liu, Yudai Wang, and Yiwei Liu
ObjectiveNickel-based superalloys are typically used as turbine disks and turbine blade materials in aeroengines owing to their excellent high-temperature performance. Because of the different service conditions of the turbine disk and turbine blade, the premature failure of joints can be avoided using gradient materials. However, a change in the composition of the gradient transition zone can change the microstructure, which significantly affects the properties of the alloy. Therefore, the evolution of the microstructure and the hardness of laser melted nickel based superalloys must be investigated, providing a basis for the laser additive manufacturing of gradient nickel-based superalloys.MethodsThe materials used in this experiment are IC10 directional superalloy and FGH9X powder superalloy with a particle size of 0.15-0.25 mm. IC10 and FGH9X powders are prepared as nickel-based superalloy powders with different compositions, and alloy ingots with 11 typical gradient components are prepared by changing the ratio of the two alloys. (From samples F100 to F0, the mass fraction of FGH9X decreases by 10% intervals, and the mass fraction of IC10 increases by 10% intervals. For example, the FGH9X mass fraction of the F80 sample is 80% and the IC10 mass fraction is 20%). A 50 g nickel-based superalloy mixed powder is prepared and placed in a copper crucible. The laser power and opening time are set to 5 kW and 2 s, respectively. A melting experiment is performed in an argon atmosphere, and the alloy ingot samples are obtained after air cooling. The microstructures of the samples are observed using an optical microscope (Leica DM4M) and scanning electron microscope (Apreo S LoVac). The primary dendrite spacing, γ' phase size, and γ' phase content are measured using the Image Pro Plus software. Thermo-Calc 2020b is used to simulate the nucleation driving force of the γ' phase in the alloys. A hardness test is performed using a micro Vickers hardness tester (MH-6) with a load of 4.9 N and a holding time of 15 s.Results and DiscussionsThe microstructure of the 11 nickel based alloy samples prepared via laser melting is composed of dendrites, and primary and secondary dendrites. When the sample changes from F100 to F0, the dendrite morphology of the alloys remains almost unchanged, and the primary dendrite spacing is in the range of 100-120 μm. Based on literature review, the dendrite morphology and dendrite spacing of the alloys are primarily affected by the cooling conditions, and the effect of alloy composition is insignificant. An analysis of the alloy microstructure shows that the 11 types of nickel-based alloys are composed of the γ and γ′ phase, carbides, and the γ/γ′ eutectic phase (Fig. 3). When the alloy composition changes from F100 to F0, the content and size of the γ′ phase increase continuously (Fig. 5), which is due to the gradual increase in Al and Ta contents in the alloys. The nucleation driving force of the γ' phase increases and more γ' phases precipitate. In addition, owing to element segregation, the content and size of the interdendritic γ' phase differ significantly from those of the dendritic trunk γ' phase. The content of γ' phase in interdendritic zone is more than that in dendritic trunk and the size of γ' phase in interdendritic zone is larger than that in dendritic trunk. In addition, the results show that the change in alloy composition does not significantly affect the microhardness, and that the overall hardness value is approximately 500 HV. This is because as the alloy composition changes from F100 to F0, the content of solid-solution strengthening elements and the content of carbides with high hardness and brittleness in the alloys decrease gradually, whereas the hardness and size of the γ' phase increase gradually; therefore, the hardness of the 11 types of nickel-based alloys is similar.ConclusionsPrimary dendrite and secondary dendrite arms are developed in the microstructures of the 11 types of nickel-based superalloy ingots prepared via laser rapid melting. The change in alloy composition does not significantly affect the dendrite morphology, and the average primary dendrite spacing is 110 μm. The microstructures of the alloys are composed of the γ phase, γ′ phase, carbides, and the γ/γ′ eutectic phase. As the powder nickel-based alloy content in alloy ingots decreases, the content and size of the γ 'phases increase continuously. As a result of element segregation, Al, Ti, Ta and Nb, which are the constituent elements of the γ 'phase, segregate in the interdendritic regions, thus causing the content and size of the γ' phase in the interdendritic regions are greater than those in the dendritic trunk. The microhardness values of the 11 samples are similar, and the overall hardness value is approximately 500 HV.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402019 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL220607
Characteristics and Elimination Method of Dense Porosity Defects in Laser Melting Deposition Connection Region of AlSi10Mg Formed with Selected Laser Melting
Jikang Fu, Hongjun Liu, Jibin Zhao, Yuhui Zhao, Chen He, and Zhiguo Wang
ObjectiveAiming at the dense porosity defects detected using X-ray in laser melting deposition connected AlSi10Mg alloy, which is manufactured using selective laser melting, the characteristics of the defect and its influence on the mechanical properties are analyzed, and the elimination method of the defect is also explored. Selective laser melting methods cannot prepare large-scale aerospace structural components, laser melting deposition overcomes the forming size limitations, and provides a feasible solution for the additive manufacturing of large structural components.MethodsIn this study, the AlSi10Mg alloy prepared using selective laser melting was used as the base, and a laser melting deposition connection experiment was performed. First, connection samples under different laser powers were prepared. The relationship between the distribution range of dense porosity defects and the laser power was analyzed by an X-ray inspection, and the effect of dense porosity on the microhardness of the connection region was measured. The dense porosity was observed and analyzed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to determine its type and formation mechanism. Then, a substrate preheating experiment was performed to explore the best preheating temperature, which is used to solve the dense porosity defects in the connection region. Finally, the microhardness and tensile properties of the connection region before and after preheating were tested, and the fracture morphology was analyzed.Results and DiscussionsThe inspection of the prepared connection samples with different energy densities shows that the dense porosity primarily appeared at the position of the interface fusion line between the connection region and substrate, and the dense porosity decreases the microhardness of the bonding zone (Fig. 7). Using SEM to observe the dense porosity, it is discovered that the porosity is primarily hydrogen porosity (Fig. 9). The solubility of hydrogen in molten pool decreases fastly, causing most bubbles to escape and form bubbles. However, the bubbles rise slowly, giving numerous bubbles no time to escape. So, some dense porosity defects are formed in this position. The preheating experiment shows that the optimum preheating temperature is higher than 100 ℃, which can effectively solve the dense porosity defects. The hardness at the fusion line reaches 90.8 HV after preheating (Fig. 14); the tensile strength is 287 MPa, and the elongation is 5.0% (Fig. 15). The observation of the fracture morphology shows that the fracture types before and after preheating are all brittle fractures and numerous dimples and quasi-cleavage morphologies can be observed on the fracture surface (Fig. 17).ConclusionsDense porosity is the primary defect of the AlSi10Mg alloy, which is produced using laser melting deposition. The defect is located at the position of the interface fusion line between the connection region and substrate, which is characterized as a watermark phenomenon on the X-ray inspection film. The accumulation of dense porosity results in a much lower hardness at the fusion line than in the connection zone and substrate. Preheating can effectively change the agglomeration effect of the dense porosity, making them evenly dispersed from the fusion line to the connection region. The mechanical properties of the samples after preheating were significantly improved. The hardness at the fusion line increased by 45% compared with that without preheating. The tensile strength increased by 19%, and the elongation increased to 5.0%.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402017 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL211621
Simulation of Crater Morphology of Paint at Laser Single Pulse
Wenfeng Yang, Dehui Lin, Mian Zhong, Shaolong Li, Ziran Qian, Guochun Liu, Yu Cao, Yi Xu, Guo Li, and Sai Zhang
ObjectiveUnderstanding the crater morphology on the surface of a paint layer after a single laser pulse can effectively suppress the superposition effects of multiple laser parameters and the photothermal and photomechanical effects of a pulse overlap. This helps reveal the laser-material interaction mechanism and provides a basis for the optimization of laser parameters. In recent years, many scholars have simulated the morphology of craters on the surface of a paint layer with the help of finite element software after nanosecond pulsed laser action based on the ablation mechanism. The laser parameters are then optimized based on the simulation results. For nanosecond pulsed lasers, the main mechanism of the laser-material interaction varies at different energy densities (the main mechanism is the ablation mechanism at low energy density, and the plasma shock and thermal radiation mechanism at high energy density). The ablation mechanism, plasma shock, and thermal radiation mechanism have different effects on the morphology of the crater. This study aims to establish a model of the damage form and the removal process of the paint layer during a single pulse of a nanosecond laser under different energy densities, to reveal the differences in the influence of the laser-material mechanism on the morphology of craters under different energy densities, and to provide a reference for the precise control and parameter optimization of the paint removal effect at high and low energy densities.MethodsA nanosecond pulsed laser with a wavelength of 1064 nm and beam energy following a Gaussian distribution was applied to the epoxy primer surface. The diameter, depth, and three-dimensional morphology data of the craters on the surface of the paint layer were measured using a 3D optical surface profiler after the laser pulse. A simulation model of crater morphology was established based on the ablation mechanism and the fitting relationship between the depth (d) of the craters and energy densities (F). MATLAB was used to simulate the morphology of the craters in the energy density range of 13.58-27.16 J/cm2, and an experimental verification was carried out. Error analysis of the experimental and simulation results under a high density revealed the influence of the plasma shock and thermal radiation mechanism on the morphology of the crater. The model correction and experimental verification were carried out based on the plasma shock and thermal radiation mechanisms.Results and DiscussionsThe simulation model of crater morphology based on the ablation mechanism has an error of less than 5% for crater depth and diameter at a low energy density (13.58-16.98 J/cm2), less than 5% for crater depth error at a high energy density (20.37-27.16 J/cm2), and up to 40% for diameter error (Fig.5). The error analysis shows that at a high energy density, the plasma shock and thermal radiation mechanisms are the main reason for the diameter error (Fig.7). After the model was corrected based on the above analysis, the diameter and depth errors of the craters under a high energy density were controlled within 5%, which significantly improved the accuracy of the model (Fig.9). The model shows that at a low energy density, the surface of the crater is approximately rotated paraboloid, and the profile of the crater is similar to a parabola; at a high energy density, the surface of the crater can be regarded as a combination of multiple normally-distributed surfaces, and the crater profile as a combination of multiple normal distribution curves.ConclusionsAt different energy densities, differences in the laser-material mechanism are noted; the ablation mechanism at a low energy density and the laser plasma shock and thermal radiation mechanisms at a high energy density are the main interaction mechanisms. Differences in the laser-material interaction mechanisms cause damage to the paint layer. Compared to the ablation mechanism, the plasma shock and thermal radiation mechanisms lead to an increase in the amount of paint removed near the surface of the crater and a wider profile near the crater surface. A simulation model of crater morphology is established for different laser-material mechanisms, thereby effectively improving the model accuracy. The study results provide a reference for the accurate control of the laser paint removal process and the optimization of paint removal parameters under high and low energy densities.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402016 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL220627
Eutectic Behavior and Wear and Corrosion Resistance Mechanisms of FeCoNiCrNb0.5Mo0.25 High-Entropy Alloy Laser Cladding Layer Microstructure
Zijun Zhou, Fulin Jiang, Fazhan Yang, Yuling Wang, Yong Yang, Pengfang Song, and Zhaolin Zhong
ObjectiveThe stern shaft is an important device for the power transmission of ships. However, corrosion is the main failure mode for stern shafts, which are subjected to the attack of Cl- and microorganisms in seawater for a long time in a marine environment with high salt and humidity. The vibration and shock of the ship stern shaft aggravate the wear of the stern shaft. The traditional anticorrosion strengthening of the ship stern shaft surface involves coating its surface with anticorrosion coatings, such as ethylene resin, epoxy resin, and chlorinated rubber. Although these anticorrosion coatings protect ship stern shafts to a certain extent, most are toxic and harm the natural environment, which seriously violates the current trend of green development. Therefore, developing a green, clean, and pollution-free surface modification method for ship stern shafts has not only economic value, but also broad environmental value. An attempt is being made to develop a eutectic high-entropy alloy based on laser cladding technology to provide an effective method for green anticorrosion and wear-resistant modification of ship stern shaft surfaces.MethodsThe base material was 42CrMo steel. In an argon atmosphere, FeCoNiCrNb0.5Mo0.25 high-entropy alloy cladding layers were prepared using a laser with a spot diameter of 4 mm and a scanning speed of 3 mm/s at five different laser powers (1200, 1300, 1400, 1500, and 1600 W). The phase compositions of the cladding layers were analyzed using X-ray diffraction. The microstructures of the cladding layers were observed by scanning electron microscopy. The hardness values of the cladding layers were measured using a Vickers hardness tester. Friction and wear experiments were conducted using a multifunctional friction and wear tester. The corrosion resistances of the cladding layers were tested using an electrochemical workstation.Results and DiscussionsWith the increase in laser power, the molten pool depth of the high-entropy alloy cladding layers increases (Fig. 3). FeCoNiCrNb0.5Mo0.25 entropy alloy cladding layers prepared using different laser powers are composed of an incomplete eutectic structure of FCC and Laves phases. With an increase in laser power, the content of lamellar nano-eutectic structure first increases and then decreases. The eutectic microstructure can be promoted by increasing the laser power appropriately, but too high laser power results in a stronger dilution effect of Fe in the substrate on the high-entropy alloy cladding layer, which weakens the promoting effect of Mo and Nb on the eutectic microstructure. The microstructure of the high-entropy alloy cladding layer prepared using a laser power of 1400 W is better than that of high-entropy alloy cladding layers prepared using other laser powers, and the microstructure is nano-eutectic with a lamellar spacing of approximately 86 nm. The increase in the laser power reduces the average hardness of the cladding layer, and the high-entropy alloy cladding layer sample prepared at laser power of 1200 W has the highest microhardness of 665.8 HV1.0, which is approximately 2.34 times that of the substrate (Fig. 5). With an increase in the laser power, the wear resistance of the FeCoNiCrNb0.5Mo0.25 high-entropy alloy cladding layer first increases and then decreases (Fig. 11). The high-entropy alloy cladding layer (1400 W cladding layer) sample owns excellent eutectic structure and the best wear resistance, with the lowest wear rate of 0.079 mm3·N-1·m-1. Compared with the substrate, the FeCoNiCrNb0.5Mo0.25 high-entropy alloy cladding layers have better corrosion resistance. However, there is no obvious linear relationship between the laser power and corrosion resistance of the high-entropy alloy cladding layer (Table 7). The lowest self-corrosion current density of the FeCoNiCrNb0.5Mo0.25 high-entropy alloy cladding layer is 1.716×10-6 A·cm-2. The existence of a eutectic structure reduces the corrosion resistance of the cladding layer to some extent. The corrosion resistance of the 1400 W cladding layer with a better eutectic structure is poor, and the self-corrosion current density is 4.332×10-6 A·cm-2.ConclusionsLaser power affects the microstructure by changing the content of the cladding layer elements and solidification conditions. Properly increasing the laser power can promote the eutectic microstructure, but too high laser power strengthens the dilution effect of Fe in the matrix on the high-entropy alloy cladding layer and weakens the promotion effect of Mo and Nb on the eutectic microstructure. With an increase in the laser power, the microhardness of the cladding layers decreases owing to the increase in substrate dilution. The wear mechanisms of high-entropy-alloy cladding layers include oxidation wear, adhesion wear, and abrasive wear. The oxide film on the worn surface plays a significant role in protecting the lower metal. The eutectic structure with alternating soft and hard distributions reduces the material loss, and the cladding layer prepared at 1400 W has the lowest wear rate. In 3.5% NaCl solution, corrosion occurs around the oxide on the cladding layer surface, and the existence of a eutectic structure intensifies galvanic corrosion and reduces corrosion resistance.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402011 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL220498
Hot Corrosion Resistance of 8YSZ Thermal Barrier Coating Modified by Laser Alloying
Lei Sun, Yujia Guo, Panpan Zhang, Rong Liu, Qunli Zhang, and Jianhua Yao
ObjectiveThermal barrier coatings can protect hot end components from high temperature, high pressure, and high stresses, which are extensively applied in gas turbine engine blades, combustion chamber, and ducting and nozzle guide vanes. However, many impurities (sodium, sulfur) exist in the operating gases and fuels, condensation of which leads to the formation of molten corrosive salts during the long-time service process, which may lead to the serious hot corrosion failure and reduce the lifetime of thermal barrier coatings. Plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings possess the typical characteristic of pores and laminar structure, which may provide penetration paths for molten corrosive salts into the coating. To improve the hot corrosion resistance, it is necessary to produce a denser layer to prevent molten salts from penetrating into porous coatings. Laser alloying technology has the advantages of high energy density, short action time, and reliable processing quality, and thus can change the loose porous structure of the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings. Meanwhile, the oxidation reaction of self-healing materials at high temperature can produce some oxidation products, which can further fill the pores and cracks in the porous coatings. Therefore, the combination of laser alloying technology and self-healing materials is an alternative method to improve the hot corrosion resistance of thermal barrier coatings, which is few reported. The purpose of this paper is to study the effect of laser alloying on the microstructure, phase composition, and hot corrosion properties of thermal barrier coatings.MethodsIn this study, the double-layer thermal barrier coatings of NiCrAlY/8YSZ were deposited onto superalloy substrate via air plasma spraying. The mixture powders of TiAl3 particles with 10% mass fraction and Ceria and Yttria-stabilized Zirconia (CYSZ) ceramic were pre-placed on the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings, and then processed using a fiber-coupled semiconductor laser. The mixture of 25% NaCl and 75% Na2SO4 as the corrosive salts was spread on the surface of the plasma-sprayed and laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings with deposition content of 10 mg/cm2. The hot corrosion test was conducted in a furnace at 900 ℃ for 4 h. Finally, the microstructure, phase composition and hot corrosion behaviors of the plasma-sprayed and laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings were systematically investigated.Results and DiscussionsAfter the laser alloying treatment, the porous and laminar microstructures in the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings were eliminated. As a result, dense columnar crystal structure and some segmented microcracks were formed in the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings (Fig. 2). The detrimental monoclinic zirconia (m-ZrO2) disappears after the air plasma spraying and the laser alloying treatment, and all phases in the 8YSZ powder turn to non-equilibrium tetragonal zirconia (t'-ZrO2) and cubic zirconia (c-ZrO2) (Fig. 3). Because of the rapid cooling and solidification rate of air plasma spraying and laser alloying treatment, the phase transformation of t'-ZrO2 to m-ZrO2 is restrained. After the hot corrosion at 900 ℃ for 4 h in molten salts (25% NaCl+75% Na2SO4), the corrosion products of Y2(SO4)3 and m-ZrO2 were found in the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings, and Y2(SO4)3 and Al2O3 were detected in the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings [Figs. 5(a) and (b)]. Compared with the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings, there are less corrosion products on the surface of the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings [Fig. 4(b) and Fig. 6(b)]. Therefore, the hot corrosion resistance of the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings is superior to that of the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings. On the one hand, the dense columnar structure in the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings can inhibit the penetration of molten salts; on the other hand, the self-healing agent TiAl3 undergoes oxidation reaction at high temperature, and the formed Al2O3 and a small amount of TiO2 can fill the cracks, which can further reduce the hot corrosion reaction between molten salts and yttria stabilizer [Figs. 9(c), (d), and (e)].ConclusionsIn this study, a typical double-layer 8YSZ/NiCrAlY thermal barrier coating was prepared via air plasma spraying technology, and then the self-healing agent TiAl3 was introduced into the thermal barrier coatings through laser alloying technology. Microstructure, phase composition, and hot corrosion properties of the plasma-sprayed and the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings were investigated. The surface of the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings is relatively rough, and there are many microcracks and pores within it. While the surface of the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings is smooth, and some fine segmented microcracks and dense columnar crystals are formed. After the hot corrosion in the 25% NaCl+75% Na2SO4 molten salt at 900 ℃ for 4 h, it was found that there were corrosion products Y2(SO4)3 and harmful m-ZrO2 in the plasma-sprayed and the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings; however, less corrosion products existed in the latter. The hot corrosion resistance of the laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings is much better than that of the plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings. On the one hand, the oxidation reaction of self-healing agent TiAl3 during the process of high-temperature hot corrosion produces Al2O3 and less TiO2, and they can fill some cracks in the coating and reduce the penetration paths of the corrosion salts. On the other hand, the laser-alloyed layer with dense columnar structure can inhibit the penetration of molten salt and reduce the occurrence of thermal corrosion reaction. Finally, the hot corrosion resistance of laser-alloyed thermal barrier coatings is greatly improved.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402002 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL220433
Effect of Microstructural Anisotropy on Corrosion Resistance of 316L Stainless Steel Prepared by Additive Manufacturing
Zhijun Zheng, Lingyan Mao, and Zhihao Dong
ObjectiveSelective laser melting (SLM) is a commonly used technology for the additive manufacturing (AM) of metal material. It uses a high-energy laser beam to melt the metal powder layer-by-layer and finally prints the desired parts. During the SLM process, the printed part on the top plane (the XOY plane in Fig. 2 in the vertical printing direction) and the printed part on the side plane (the YOZ plane in Fig. 2 in the parallel printing direction) have different heating histories and temperature gradients. Therefore, the two planes have significantly different microstructures. This anisotropy in the microstructure is bound to introduce anisotropy to the performance. Recently, several studies have been conducted on the effect of microstructural anisotropy on mechanical properties. The unified conclusion is that printed samples have better mechanical properties in the vertical printing direction than in the parallel printing direction. However, few studies have been conducted on the effect of microstructural anisotropy on the corrosion behavior of printed parts, and their conclusions are different. Therefore, it is necessary to further investigate this issue. The aim of this study is to investigate the corrosion behaviors in different directions (the XOY and YOZ planes) in 316L stainless steel (SS) prepared using SLM through electrochemical measurements and propose internal causes of these corrosion behaviors, which have not yet been described.MethodsThe 316L SS parts are first prepared using SLM. To obtain samples in different directions, including the XOY and YOZ planes, samples are cut according to the diagram shown in Fig. 3. In this study, the forged 316L SS is used as the counterpart after solution treatment. The body and surface density of 316L SS are measured using the Archimedes drainage and metallographic methods, respectively. The microstructures of the SLMed sample on XOY and YOZ planes are characterized by electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) and a scanning electron microscope (SEM). The phase structures of all samples are measured by X-ray diffractometry (XRD). The corrosion behaviors are explored by measuring the open-circuit potential (OCP), potentiodynamic polarization, and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). In addition, the internal causes of this effect can be explained by the potentiostatic polarization and characterization of the surface topographies of all parts after corrosion.Results and DiscussionsThe results show that the body density of 316L SS prepared using SLM is 99.38%, which is close to that of its forged counterpart (99.7%). The surface densities of the SLMed sample on XOY and YOZ planes are 99.7% and 99.87%, respectively, indicating that the surface densities in the different directions are almost similar. The XRD results confirm that the additive manufacturing technology does not change the phase structure of the 316L SS (Fig. 5). However, a clear discrepancy is evident in the grain orientation for both planes from the EBSD tests (Fig. 7). On the XOY plane, more (101)-oriented grains are observed, whereas on the YOZ plane, more (111)-oriented grains are observed. According to the literature [26], (111)-oriented grains are more resistant to corrosion. The grain sizes in both planes differ slightly according to the EBSD test results (Fig. 8). The average grain size of the SLMed sample on the YOZ plane (9.51 μm) is slightly larger than that of the SLMed sample on the XOY plane (7.35 μm). However, the grain sizes of SLMed sample on XOY and YOZ planes are significantly smaller than that of the forged counterpart (50-100 μm). The results from the electrochemical tests show that the corrosion resistance of the SLMed sample on the XOY plane is better than that of the SLMed sample on the YOZ plane, and the SLMed sample on both planes are superior to the forged counterpart, as confirmed by the OCP measurements (Fig. 9), potentiodynamic polarization curves (Fig. 10), and EIS measurements (Fig. 11). The improved corrosion resistance of the SLMed sample on the XOY plane is attributed to the fewer (111)-oriented grains on the XOY plane, and consequently, to the more compact passive film formed on the XOY plane based on the results of potentiostatic polarization measurements (Fig. 12). These conclusions are further confirmed by observing the SEM morphologies of the three corroded samples. The sizes of the inclusions on the XOY and YOZ planes of the printed samples are much smaller than those of the forged part (Fig. 13). In addition, the inclusion on the XOY plane remains closely combined with the matrix after corrosion, demonstrating outstanding corrosion resistance. However, for both the SLMed sample on the YOZ plane and its forged counterpart, the case worsens. A clear corrosion gap is present around the inclusions after corrosion, particularly for the forged counterpart, indicating poorer corrosion resistance.ConclusionsFirst, compact 316L SS samples are produced using SLM. Their densities are 99.38%, which are considerably close to that of the forged parts (99.7%). There is a notable difference in the microstructure between the XOY and YOZ planes in the printed part. On the XOY plane, more (101)-oriented grains are observed. However, on the YOZ plane, more (111)-oriented grains are observed. This microstructural anisotropy has a significant effect on the corrosion behavior of 316L SS printed using SLM. The corrosion resistance of the SLMed sample on the XOY plane is better than that on the YOZ plane, and the SLMed samples on both planes are superior to their forged counterparts. The better corrosion resistance of the SLMed sample on the XOY plane results from fewer (111)-oriented grains, leading to more compact passive films formed on the surface. The SEM morphologies of inclusions in the three corroded samples show that the size of the inclusions on the XOY plane is smaller than that on the YOZ plane and that of forged counterpart. In addition, the corrosion gap between the inclusion and matrix on the XOY plane is far less than that on the YOZ plane and that of forged counterpart, indicating better corrosion resistance.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402012 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL220629
Microstructure of Recast Layer During High Power Laser Cutting of Thick Plates
Xiuquan Ma, Libo Wang, Zhengwu Zhu, Chunming Wang, and Gaoyang Mi
ObjectiveOwing to the excellent strength, plasticity, and corrosion resistance, 316L stainless steel is widely used in nuclear and chemical industries. The efficient cutting of thick plates is realized using lasers, which are high-energy-density heat sources. During the laser cutting process, the plate material melts and is blown off vertically under the action of a coaxial compressed gas. Therefore, a kerf is formed. During a rapid thermal cycle, an extremely thin recast layer (the order of microns) is formed on the surface of the kerf. During the solidification of the recast layer, a particular temperature gradient and fluid motion significantly influence the morphology and the texture of the structure at room temperature. In previous studies, researchers have mainly focused on the influence of parameters, such as laser power, cutting speed, and pressure of compressed gas, on the cut formation and its quality. Few studies have focused on the microstructural morphology and formation mechanism of the recast layer. The differences between the as-solidified microstructure and the substrate may lead to non-negligible changes in the properties of the edge, which in turn affects the overall characteristics. To study the morphology and microstructural growth of the recast layer, an 18 mm thick 316L austenitic stainless steel plate is taken as the object of laser cutting for this study. The solidification mechanism of the recast layer at different kerf sites during the laser cutting process is revealed.MethodsAn 18 mm thick 316L austenitic stainless steel plate was employed as the base metal for this study. A pulsed laser was used to cut the base metal to form a kerf. N2 was chosen as the compressed gas, and its flow direction was coaxial with the laser. Representative specimens were then sampled to analyze their surfaces. Transverse and surficial microstructural morphologies of the recast layer, under the laser action, were analyzed using scanning electron microscopy and electron back scattering diffraction (EBSD). In addition, the recast surfaces were cleaned using anhydrous ethanol. The transverse surfaces were treated using coarse grinding, fine grinding, and polishing techniques. The polished surface was then etched with diluted aqua regia (volume ratio of HCl, HNO3 and H2O is 3∶1∶4).Results and DiscussionsThe distribution of the main elements on the surface of the recast layer is analyzed using energy dispersive spectroscopy. The results indicate that no significant element change occurred along the thickness, except for a slight loss of Fe (Table 5). The grain growth mode of the recast layer is further analyzed using EBSD at the 1/3 site from kerf top and the kerf bottom site . The results indicate that epitaxial growth is the primary growth mode. However, the proportion of non-epitaxial growth at the 1/3 site from kerf top (Fig. 5) is observed to be higher than that at the bottom site (Fig. 7). A comparison between the IPF orientation distribution and pole figures in Figs. 9 and 10 also shows that the grain growth at the 1/3 site from kerf top exhibits some fluctuations with unmixed and unperturbed features.ConclusionsThe results show that a small amount of Fe evaporates from the recast layer surface. A variation in flow state from turbulent at the top to laminar at the bottom surface is observed, with an increase in thickness and needle-like grains. For crystal orientation, the ratio of the epitaxial growth at the top surface of the recast layer is lower than that at the bottom surface. Such a random distribution of epitaxial growth is caused by the turbulent flow at the former, whereas the dominant epitaxial growth is induced by the laminar flow at the latter. Considering the grain profiles, the γ phase in the base metal is equiaxed, whereas the δ phase is arranged in a banded form. The morphology of the γ phase grains in the recast layer is irregular and coarsen by approximately 2 times compared to those of the base metal. However, the δ phase is dispersed and refined from 1/6 to 1/2 of the base metal. Under the conditions of an extremely high-temperature gradient and a disordered disturbance owing to melting, a substantially reduced duration of δ phase formation with considerable dispersion is produced.
  • Feb. 25, 2023
  • Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 50, Issue 4, 0402015 (2023)
  • DOI:10.3788/CJL220611